Wednesday, August 28, 2013

U.S. court rejects firm's challenge to Obamacare contraception mandate

(Reuters) - A divided federal appeals court on Friday rejected a Pennsylvania cabinet maker's religion-based challenge to the 2010 healthcare law's requirement that larger companies provide workers with health insurance covering birth control.
The decision created a split among federal appeals courts, boosting the chance that the U.S. Supreme Court may step in to resolve the dispute over challenges to the provision in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, known as Obamacare.
By a 2-1 vote, a panel of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia ruled against Conestoga Wood Specialties Corp, whose owners are Mennonite Christians, in finding that "for-profit, secular corporations cannot engage in religious exercise."
The decision departed from a June 27 ruling by the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver favoring the arts and crafts retailer Hobby Lobby Stores Inc, in which it said for-profit companies can sometimes assert religious rights.
Lawyers for Conestoga did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The East Earl, Pennsylvania, company, which employs 950 people and is owned by the Hahn family, said the contraception mandate violated its rights under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA).
After a lower court refused to issue an injunction, Conestoga appealed, and its lawyer told the 3rd Circuit that the company was complying with the law during its appeal. Failure to comply subjects companies with 50 or more employees to daily fines that can grow quickly.
NO SIMILAR HISTORY
Like the 10th Circuit, the 3rd Circuit reviewed the Supreme Court's 2010 decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission that gave companies a broad First Amendment right to engage in political spending through independent campaign groups.
But Circuit Judge Robert Cowen, writing for the 3rd Circuit majority, said that while there was "a long history of protecting corporations' rights to free speech," there was no similar history of protection for the free exercise of religion.
"We simply cannot understand how a for-profit, secular corporation - apart from its owners - can exercise religion," he wrote. "A holding to the contrary ... would eviscerate the fundamental principle that a corporation is a legally distinct entity from its owners."
Noting that the 10th Circuit said such corporations may raise some free exercise of religion and RFRA claims, Cowen said, "We respectfully disagree with that court's analysis."
Circuit Judge Kent Jordan dissented, saying the majority decision reflected a "cramped and confused understanding" of religious rights granted by Congress and the U.S. Constitution.
"Government should be enjoined from telling sincere believers in the sanctity of life to put their consciences aside and support other people's reproductive choices," he wrote.
The Supreme Court hears oral arguments in about 75 to 80 cases per year. Typically, more than half involve issues where lower courts are divided.
The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, a nonprofit law firm that has argued against the contraception mandate, has said there are about 63 lawsuits nationwide challenging the mandate.
The case is Conestoga Wood Specialties Corp et al v. Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services et al, 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 13-1144.

Weiita Starlight Headlamp Rechargeable High Low Strobe Modes Zoom Adjustable 6631

Weiita Starlight Headlamp Rechargeable High Low Strobe Modes Zoom Adjustable 6631

Compare Weiita Starlight Headlamp Rechargeable High Low Strobe Modes Zoom Adjustable 6631

Smith and Wesson Delta Compact Penlight Combo Flashlight Black

Smith and Wesson Delta Compact Penlight Combo Flashlight Black

Compare Smith and Wesson Delta Compact Penlight Combo Flashlight Black

Northstates 4638 Wide Stairway Swing Gate

Northstates 4638 Wide Stairway Swing Gate

Compare Northstates 4638 Wide Stairway Swing Gate

JazzyToes Baby girls Newborn Cable Knit Slipper Pink 6 12 Months

JazzyToes Baby girls Newborn Cable Knit Slipper Pink 6 12 Months

Compare JazzyToes Baby girls Newborn Cable Knit Slipper Pink 6 12 Months

Young Hearts Baby Girls Infant 2 Piece Pink Infant Girls Knit Shirt And Short Set Pink 24 Months

Young Hearts Baby Girls Infant 2 Piece Pink Infant Girls Knit Shirt And Short Set Pink 24 Months

Compare Young Hearts Baby Girls Infant 2 Piece Pink Infant Girls Knit Shirt And Short Set Pink 24 Months

KerrBear Kids Pink Zebra print Leg Warmers

KerrBear Kids Pink Zebra print Leg Warmers

Compare KerrBear Kids Pink Zebra print Leg Warmers

Sea to Summit Ultra Sil Pack Liner Small 50 Liter Sky Blue

Sea to Summit Ultra Sil Pack Liner Small 50 Liter Sky Blue

Compare Sea to Summit Ultra Sil Pack Liner Small 50 Liter Sky Blue

Akademiks Newborn Girls 3pc Green Bodysuit Pant Set 0 3M

Akademiks Newborn Girls 3pc Green Bodysuit Pant Set 0 3M

Compare Akademiks Newborn Girls 3pc Green Bodysuit Pant Set 0 3M

OiOi Baby Bags SM Original Grey Medium Grey

OiOi Baby Bags SM Original Grey Medium Grey

Compare OiOi Baby Bags SM Original Grey Medium Grey

Skidders Indoor Monster Truck Baby Gripper Socks 12 Months

Skidders Indoor Monster Truck Baby Gripper Socks 12 Months

Compare Skidders Indoor Monster Truck Baby Gripper Socks 12 Months

A Pair And A Spare Floppy Ears Pink Bunny Security Blanket

A Pair And A Spare Floppy Ears Pink Bunny Security Blanket

Compare A Pair And A Spare Floppy Ears Pink Bunny Security Blanket

Levi s Piping Pockets Stretch Skinny Jeans Sizes 12M 24M mysterious 3 6 months

Levi s Piping Pockets Stretch Skinny Jeans Sizes 12M 24M mysterious 3 6 months

Compare Levi s Piping Pockets Stretch Skinny Jeans Sizes 12M 24M mysterious 3 6 months

Grandoe Kids EZ On Glove Pink Rush Large

Grandoe Kids EZ On Glove Pink Rush Large

Compare Grandoe Kids EZ On Glove Pink Rush Large

Sashas Rain and Wind Cover for Graco DuoGlider Tandem Stroller

Sashas Rain and Wind Cover for Graco DuoGlider Tandem Stroller

Compare Sashas Rain and Wind Cover for Graco DuoGlider Tandem Stroller

Newco International Kids Bean Chair Football

Newco International Kids Bean Chair Football

Compare Newco International Kids Bean Chair Football

Jefferies Socks Baby Girls Newborn Christmas 3 Pair Gift Box Gingerbread Newborn

Jefferies Socks Baby Girls Newborn Christmas 3 Pair Gift Box Gingerbread Newborn

Compare Jefferies Socks Baby Girls Newborn Christmas 3 Pair Gift Box Gingerbread Newborn

Eurosocks Digits Silver Board Sock Black Small

Eurosocks Digits Silver Board Sock Black Small

Compare Eurosocks Digits Silver Board Sock Black Small

Babylegs Baby Girls Infant Big Top Purple One Size

Babylegs Baby Girls Infant Big Top Purple One Size

Compare Babylegs Baby Girls Infant Big Top Purple One Size

aden anais Muslin Hooded Towel Washcloth Set Bathing Beauty

aden anais Muslin Hooded Towel Washcloth Set Bathing Beauty

Compare aden anais Muslin Hooded Towel Washcloth Set Bathing Beauty

Sasha Kiddie Uppa 1R UPPAbaby Vista Single Stroller Rain and Wind Cover Stroller Not Included

Sasha Kiddie Uppa 1R UPPAbaby Vista Single Stroller Rain and Wind Cover Stroller Not Included

Compare Sasha Kiddie Uppa 1R UPPAbaby Vista Single Stroller Rain and Wind Cover Stroller Not Included

Bedtime Originals Musical Mobile Magic Kingdom

Bedtime Originals Musical Mobile Magic Kingdom

Compare Bedtime Originals Musical Mobile Magic Kingdom

JJ Cole 0 6 Months Soft Bib Primary Elephants

JJ Cole 0 6 Months Soft Bib Primary Elephants

Compare JJ Cole 0 6 Months Soft Bib Primary Elephants

Hot Dog Foil Wraps 500 Wraps Per case

Hot Dog Foil Wraps 500 Wraps Per case

Compare Hot Dog Foil Wraps 500 Wraps Per case

Little Me Baby Girls Petit Posy Tunic Set Pink Floral 6 Months

Little Me Baby Girls Petit Posy Tunic Set Pink Floral 6 Months

Compare Little Me Baby Girls Petit Posy Tunic Set Pink Floral 6 Months

Tuesday, August 27, 2013

Cocoon Egyptian Cotton MummyLiner Khaki 95 Inch x 35 22 Inch

Cocoon Egyptian Cotton MummyLiner Khaki 95 Inch x 35 22 Inch

Compare Cocoon Egyptian Cotton MummyLiner Khaki 95 Inch x 35 22 Inch

2 B Real Tie Dye Wavelength 1 Piece Swimsuit Sizes 12M 24M yellow 12 months

2 B Real Tie Dye Wavelength 1 Piece Swimsuit Sizes 12M 24M yellow 12 months

Compare 2 B Real Tie Dye Wavelength 1 Piece Swimsuit Sizes 12M 24M yellow 12 months

ABSORBA Baby Girls Newborn Love Coverall White 0 3 Months

ABSORBA Baby Girls Newborn Love Coverall White 0 3 Months

Compare ABSORBA Baby Girls Newborn Love Coverall White 0 3 Months

Itty Bitty Baby Snap Front Denim Diaper Shirt Preemie

Itty Bitty Baby Snap Front Denim Diaper Shirt Preemie

Compare Itty Bitty Baby Snap Front Denim Diaper Shirt Preemie

Mini Bean Baby girls Newborn Stripe Elephant Print Double Body Creeper and Denim Pant Set Orange 3 6 Months

Mini Bean Baby girls Newborn Stripe Elephant Print Double Body Creeper and Denim Pant Set Orange 3 6 Months

Compare Mini Bean Baby girls Newborn Stripe Elephant Print Double Body Creeper and Denim Pant Set Orange 3 6 Months

EIEIO Baby Bodysuit 3 6 months bodysuit

EIEIO Baby Bodysuit 3 6 months bodysuit

Compare EIEIO Baby Bodysuit 3 6 months bodysuit

SwaddleDesigns Unisex Baby Newborn 1 Inch Angry Birds Bodysuit Yellow 0 3 Months

SwaddleDesigns Unisex Baby Newborn 1 Inch Angry Birds Bodysuit Yellow 0 3 Months

Compare SwaddleDesigns Unisex Baby Newborn 1 Inch Angry Birds Bodysuit Yellow 0 3 Months

Dena Sophia Blanket

Dena Sophia Blanket

Compare Dena Sophia Blanket

Carhartt Baby Boys Infant Tee Tango Red 6 Months

Carhartt Baby Boys Infant Tee Tango Red 6 Months

Compare Carhartt Baby Boys Infant Tee Tango Red 6 Months

Kavu Women s Keeper Big Dot

Kavu Women s Keeper Big Dot

Compare Kavu Women s Keeper Big Dot

Sierra Designs Yahi 6 Person Footprint

Sierra Designs Yahi 6 Person Footprint

Compare Sierra Designs Yahi 6 Person Footprint

OshKosh B gosh Heart Overalls Blue Ribbon Blue Ribbon 3 Months

OshKosh B gosh Heart Overalls Blue Ribbon Blue Ribbon 3 Months

Compare OshKosh B gosh Heart Overalls Blue Ribbon Blue Ribbon 3 Months

New 10 piece 5000Mah LED Flashlight Torch 18650 Rechargeable Li ion Battery 3 7V From UNIONKIT

New 10 piece 5000Mah LED Flashlight Torch 18650 Rechargeable Li ion Battery 3 7V From UNIONKIT

Compare New 10 piece 5000Mah LED Flashlight Torch 18650 Rechargeable Li ion Battery 3 7V From UNIONKIT

Case Knives 023 Hawkbill Pruner 31011CV Pattern with Smooth Yellow Synthetic Handles

Case Knives 023 Hawkbill Pruner 31011CV Pattern with Smooth Yellow Synthetic Handles

Compare Case Knives 023 Hawkbill Pruner 31011CV Pattern with Smooth Yellow Synthetic Handles

Medline Aloetouch baby wipes flip top scented 15 pack case

Medline Aloetouch baby wipes flip top scented 15 pack case

Compare Medline Aloetouch baby wipes flip top scented 15 pack case

Tiddliwinks Sweet Safari Security Blanket

Tiddliwinks Sweet Safari Security Blanket

Compare Tiddliwinks Sweet Safari Security Blanket

Kids Headquarters Baby Girls Infant Stripes Top With Short Yellow 18 Months

Kids Headquarters Baby Girls Infant Stripes Top With Short Yellow 18 Months

Compare Kids Headquarters Baby Girls Infant Stripes Top With Short Yellow 18 Months

Go Power GP SWR B 24 Inverter Remote for the 24V GP SW1000 2000 3000

Go Power GP SWR B 24 Inverter Remote for the 24V GP SW1000 2000 3000

Compare Go Power GP SWR B 24 Inverter Remote for the 24V GP SW1000 2000 3000

Gerber 3 knife Field Dressing Kit

Gerber 3 knife Field Dressing Kit

Compare Gerber 3 knife Field Dressing Kit

Marvel Licensed Sleeping Bag Spiderman 2 lb

Marvel Licensed Sleeping Bag Spiderman 2 lb

Compare Marvel Licensed Sleeping Bag Spiderman 2 lb

KAVU Women s More Or Dress Black Small

KAVU Women s More Or Dress Black Small

Compare KAVU Women s More Or Dress Black Small

Kid s Bamboo Spork 2 Pack

Kid s Bamboo Spork 2 Pack

Compare Kid s Bamboo Spork 2 Pack

Dakine Machado Pro Pad Pop

Dakine Machado Pro Pad Pop

Compare Dakine Machado Pro Pad Pop

Aden and Anais Hooded Towel and Washcloth Set Hide and Sea with BONUS Rocking Green Soap and Tooth Tissue

Aden and Anais Hooded Towel and Washcloth Set Hide and Sea with BONUS Rocking Green Soap and Tooth Tissue

Compare Aden and Anais Hooded Towel and Washcloth Set Hide and Sea with BONUS Rocking Green Soap and Tooth Tissue

The First Years Soothie Wide Neck Nipple Stage 2 2 Pack

The First Years Soothie Wide Neck Nipple Stage 2 2 Pack

Compare The First Years Soothie Wide Neck Nipple Stage 2 2 Pack

Motorola TalkAbout FV200AA 5 Mile 22 Channel Two Way Radio Pair

Motorola TalkAbout FV200AA 5 Mile 22 Channel Two Way Radio Pair

Compare Motorola TalkAbout FV200AA 5 Mile 22 Channel Two Way Radio Pair